Lead-free solder, tin whiskers and bald-faced lies - Revision history

Rational Point: 96.5% tin, 0.5% copper and 3% silver

2026-04-30T03:47:03Z

96.5% tin, 0.5% copper and 3% silver

← Older revision		Revision as of 03:47, 30 April 2026
Line 5:		Line 5:
	:"… In this case, a thorough post-solder cleaning should be done to prevent flux-related problems such as corrosion, dendritic growth, poor adhesion of the conformity coatings, and electromigration, which can cause short circuits between circuit traces. … A good lead-based solder joint will be smooth and shiny, while the lead-free joints are usually duller and grainy.…"		:"… In this case, a thorough post-solder cleaning should be done to prevent flux-related problems such as corrosion, dendritic growth, poor adhesion of the conformity coatings, and electromigration, which can cause short circuits between circuit traces. … A good lead-based solder joint will be smooth and shiny, while the lead-free joints are usually duller and grainy.…"

	No. A composition of 99% tin, 0.7% copper and 0.3% silver is fine. Very nice and shiny. If the guys at work don't steal it and use it at home to solder jewelry for their wives and girlfriends. Actually, do not use jewelry solder for electronics. Even so-called "extra easy" silver solder is much too hot and hard. Silver happens to be an excellent electrical conductor, and a little bit goes a long way, while lead is a rather poor conductor of electricity, but used because of its resistance to acids.		No. A composition of 99% tin, 0.7% copper and 0.3% silver is fine. An alloy of 96.5% tin, 0.5% copper and 3% silver is also popular. Very nice and shiny. If the guys at work don't steal it and use it at home to solder jewelry for their wives and girlfriends. Actually, do not use jewelry solder for electronics. Even so-called "extra easy" silver solder is much too hot and hard. Silver happens to be an excellent electrical conductor, and a little bit goes a long way, while lead is a rather poor conductor of electricity, but used because of its resistance to acids.

	:\"Tin whiskers\" is not an imaginative, fanciful term for some aspect of electronics manufacturing. Tin whiskers are real. They are microscopic conductive fibers emanating from pure tin surfaces, and they pose a serious problem to electronics of all types. These whiskers can form electrical paths, which affect the operation of the subject device. This article discusses the problems caused by the removal of lead from electronics and describes some techniques to mitigate tin whiskers <ref>Analog Devices. ''Tin Whiskers Are Real and Complex.'' Dec 13, 2011 https://www.analog.com/en/resources/technical-articles/tin-whiskers-are-real-and-complex.html</ref>.		:\"Tin whiskers\" is not an imaginative, fanciful term for some aspect of electronics manufacturing. Tin whiskers are real. They are microscopic conductive fibers emanating from pure tin surfaces, and they pose a serious problem to electronics of all types. These whiskers can form electrical paths, which affect the operation of the subject device. This article discusses the problems caused by the removal of lead from electronics and describes some techniques to mitigate tin whiskers <ref>Analog Devices. ''Tin Whiskers Are Real and Complex.'' Dec 13, 2011 https://www.analog.com/en/resources/technical-articles/tin-whiskers-are-real-and-complex.html</ref>.

Rational Point: do not use jewelry solder

2026-04-30T03:44:19Z

do not use jewelry solder

← Older revision		Revision as of 03:44, 30 April 2026
Line 5:		Line 5:
	:"… In this case, a thorough post-solder cleaning should be done to prevent flux-related problems such as corrosion, dendritic growth, poor adhesion of the conformity coatings, and electromigration, which can cause short circuits between circuit traces. … A good lead-based solder joint will be smooth and shiny, while the lead-free joints are usually duller and grainy.…"		:"… In this case, a thorough post-solder cleaning should be done to prevent flux-related problems such as corrosion, dendritic growth, poor adhesion of the conformity coatings, and electromigration, which can cause short circuits between circuit traces. … A good lead-based solder joint will be smooth and shiny, while the lead-free joints are usually duller and grainy.…"

	No. A composition of 99% tin, 0.7% copper and 0.3% silver is fine. Very nice and shiny. If the guys at work don't steal it and use it at home to solder jewelry for their wives and girlfriends.		No. A composition of 99% tin, 0.7% copper and 0.3% silver is fine. Very nice and shiny. If the guys at work don't steal it and use it at home to solder jewelry for their wives and girlfriends. Actually, do not use jewelry solder for electronics. Even so-called "extra easy" silver solder is much too hot and hard. Silver happens to be an excellent electrical conductor, and a little bit goes a long way, while lead is a rather poor conductor of electricity, but used because of its resistance to acids.

	Silver happens to be an excellent electrical conductor, while lead is ~~very~~ poor conductor of electricity.

	:\"Tin whiskers\" is not an imaginative, fanciful term for some aspect of electronics manufacturing. Tin whiskers are real. They are microscopic conductive fibers emanating from pure tin surfaces, and they pose a serious problem to electronics of all types. These whiskers can form electrical paths, which affect the operation of the subject device. This article discusses the problems caused by the removal of lead from electronics and describes some techniques to mitigate tin whiskers <ref>Analog Devices. ''Tin Whiskers Are Real and Complex.'' Dec 13, 2011 https://www.analog.com/en/resources/technical-articles/tin-whiskers-are-real-and-complex.html</ref>.		:\"Tin whiskers\" is not an imaginative, fanciful term for some aspect of electronics manufacturing. Tin whiskers are real. They are microscopic conductive fibers emanating from pure tin surfaces, and they pose a serious problem to electronics of all types. These whiskers can form electrical paths, which affect the operation of the subject device. This article discusses the problems caused by the removal of lead from electronics and describes some techniques to mitigate tin whiskers <ref>Analog Devices. ''Tin Whiskers Are Real and Complex.'' Dec 13, 2011 https://www.analog.com/en/resources/technical-articles/tin-whiskers-are-real-and-complex.html</ref>.

	No. No. Just no. Absolutely not. Straight honest men shave and dress for work without talking about "tin whiskers." Nothing is wrong with silver solder.		No. No. Just no. Absolutely not. Straight honest men shave and dress for work without talking about "tin whiskers." Nothing is wrong with silver solder.



	Get serious. Cost is a consideration, but leaded solder suffers from cold solder joints and poor electrical conductivity, and ultimately those guys should have shaved for work and not robbed the jewelry store.		Get serious. Cost is a consideration, but leaded solder suffers from cold solder joints and poor electrical conductivity, and ultimately those guys should have shaved for work and not robbed the jewelry store.

Rational Point: robbery at the jewelry store

2026-04-29T05:50:05Z

robbery at the jewelry store

New page

The health hazards of leaded solder are probably exaggerated. Other than that, there is absolutely nothing wrong with RoHS-compliant (Restriction of Hazardous Substances) solder.

Persons who are experienced soldering by hand with leaded solder <ref>Edward Fenderson. ''ROHS vs. Non-ROHS Soldering.'' 2015-08-26 https://www.digikey.com/en/maker/blogs/rohs-vs-non-rohs-soldering</ref> may not want to change. Also, silver costs more than lead, bosses are not the ones doing that kind of work, and they don’t want to pay for silver. So hand solder jobs in the electronics industry are only for prototyping and make-work.

:"… In this case, a thorough post-solder cleaning should be done to prevent flux-related problems such as corrosion, dendritic growth, poor adhesion of the conformity coatings, and electromigration, which can cause short circuits between circuit traces. … A good lead-based solder joint will be smooth and shiny, while the lead-free joints are usually duller and grainy.…"

No. A composition of 99% tin, 0.7% copper and 0.3% silver is fine. Very nice and shiny. If the guys at work don't steal it and use it at home to solder jewelry for their wives and girlfriends.

Silver happens to be an excellent electrical conductor, while lead is very poor conductor of electricity.

:\"Tin whiskers\" is not an imaginative, fanciful term for some aspect of electronics manufacturing. Tin whiskers are real. They are microscopic conductive fibers emanating from pure tin surfaces, and they pose a serious problem to electronics of all types. These whiskers can form electrical paths, which affect the operation of the subject device. This article discusses the problems caused by the removal of lead from electronics and describes some techniques to mitigate tin whiskers <ref>Analog Devices. ''Tin Whiskers Are Real and Complex.'' Dec 13, 2011 https://www.analog.com/en/resources/technical-articles/tin-whiskers-are-real-and-complex.html</ref>.

No. No. Just no. Absolutely not. Straight honest men shave and dress for work without talking about "tin whiskers." Nothing is wrong with silver solder.

Get serious. Cost is a consideration, but leaded solder suffers from cold solder joints and poor electrical conductivity, and ultimately those guys should have shaved for work and not robbed the jewelry store.